Melbourne vendor goes to court over $1,000 no-reserve sheriff's auction of his $630,000 Braybrook home

By Jonathan Chancellor
Thursday, 09 February 2012

A Melbourne man is fighting to reverse the sheriff’s extraordinary $1,000 sale of his six-bedroom Braybrook home.

Zhiping Zhou's house was repossessed by the sheriff. It still remains in Zhou’s registered name, according to a title search, although there are warrants of claim registered on title.

The ABC reported today the Victoria Supreme Court heard the imposing two-storey brick house had an estimated value of $630,000 but was sold at auction without a reserve.

The highest bidder bought the Wirraway Avenue home for $1,000, apparently beating off a $200 bidder.

Zhou's lawyers told the court the sale was "absurd", ABC court reporter Sarah Farnsworth writes.

They have called on the judge to reverse the sale and to find the sheriff in breach of duty, the ABC reported.

"[The sale is] so short of the mark it's not a real sale," barrister Paul Hayes reportedly told the court.

He said it was hard to imagine lawmakers had intended for people like Zhou to lose out so badly.

The judge was asked to invalidate the sale or award damages. Justice Vickery is listed to continue the hearing on Friday February 10 in the Commercial and Equity division.

The man who bought the home is also being accused of taking advantage of Zhou, however his lawyer told the court the sale was legal and legally it could have been sold for one cent.

The property had been briefly listed in 2007 through Barry Plant Sunshine, according to the Australian Property Monitors auction data base. It was then listed with different agents in June 2010 with $650,000-plus hopes for its slightly postponed July 2010 auction, according to the APM report on the property.

There was a subsequent $660,000 auction offer, but it fell short of the $750,000 reserve price when listed through Burnham Real Estate.

Details and timing of the eventful sheriff's auction were not initially available, but its understood to have been about five months after the property's July listing. 

There was $465,000 owing on the property.

Burnham listing agents Khuong Vien and Tony Gerace marketed it in July 2010 as a modern double-storey family home with bedrooms for all the family to enjoy.

“Situated in a quiet residential location and nestled amongst all modern brick homes and an area to surely enjoy a bright future,” the marketing suggested.

The home comprises six bedrooms with built-in wardrobes, master with ensuite, plus study and three bathrooms and double garage.

“It was complemented with polished floor, spa, reverse cycle split systems, high ceilings and much more,” the marketing said.

The block cost $170,000 in 2003. 

Lawyers for the sheriff's office say it had no obligation to get a fair price.

The directions hearing between Zhiping Zhou versus the buyer, Ronald Geoffrey Kousal and others began with direction hearings last June in the Victorian Supreme Court.

      Did you like this article? 

      Sign up to the Property Observer Newsletter to receive a daily news wrap-up straight to your inbox AND a free eBook!

      Please enter a valid email address. For example fred@domain.com .

      Leave a Comment

      Comments (2)Add Comment
      ...
      written by Chip, February 10, 2012
      This should be an open-close case. Simple matter of quid-pro-quo. I certainly hope the sheriff loses job over this incident.
      ...
      written by Donald Topping, February 10, 2012
      Don't the public think its suspicious when the details of the auction are "unknown"?
      How do the public actually find out about these auctions? They are not regular Sherriff's actions.

      You must be logged in to post a comment. Please register if you do not have an account yet.

      busy

      Australand Carlton

      Features spectacular resident’s rooftop.
      Designed by award winning architects Fender Katsalidis and ARM Architecture, Local invites you to experience low rise boutique apartment living at its best.
      Located in a quiet tree-lined street only 400m to Lygon St & Carlton Gardens, 700m to Melbourne University and 1.3km to the CBD.
      Visit the Display Centre. Open everyday midday–3pm. Corner of Elgin & Canning Streets, Carlton.
      Enquire now 13 38 38 apartmentscarlton.com.au >>

        The Mark at Sydney's Central Park

        Central Park is the $2 billion transformation of a heritage brewery site on Sydney's Broadway into a vibrant mixed-use urban village.

        Designed by architects Johnson Pilton Walker, 'The Mark' is a soaring glass tower of sustainability, advanced building technology and applied imagination - and your opportunity to capitalise on Central Park's success.
        Register your interest now at centralparksydney.com or call 1300 857 057. >>

          Hyde Parkville Apartments

          The Best of Melbourne on your doorstep.
          Designed by renowned architects SJB, these boutique 1 & 2 BR apartments represent the best of low-rise boutique living. Residents will enjoy access to ‘The Park Club’, featuring a 25m lap pool, gymnasium and landscaped outdoor retreat with views onto the Village Oval that adjoins Hyde Parkville.
          Visit the Display Centre. Open everyday midday–3pm. Cade Way, Parkville.
          Enquire now 13 38 38 parkvilleapartments.com.au >>

            Brisbane's most exclusive acreage

            An opportunity of this calibre is a very rare event within South-East Queensland. Distinctively different and exceptionally desirable.

            Araluen presents to the market a once-in-a-lifetime chance to acquire pristine, six hectare parcels (15 acres) of magnificently manicured land.

            If you yearn for a home large and loving enough to nurture your family's dreams and aspirations, then Araluen is an unpassable opportunity.
            Register your Interest Now
              Previous
              Next
              Rethinking Australian bank business models: Christopher Joye Christopher Joye
              By compelling banks to rely on short-term retail deposits rather than wholesale funding, regulators are shifting risk onto taxpayers.
              SEARCH SITE
              Follow us Property Observer on Twitter Property Observer on Facebook Property Observer on LinkedIn Subscribe to Property Observer RSS feeds
              Monthly Payment ($)
              Sponsored Links

              Suburb Data

              Free suburb snapshots for investors

              Powered by

              Property data for Western Australia Property data for Western Australia Property data for Tasmania Property data for Queensland Property data for Northern Territory Property data for South Australia Property data for Victoria Property data for New South Wales Property data for Canberra

              Click on your state for more

              RP Data-Rismark May 17 daily index
               

              Private Media Publications

              Crikey

              loading...

              Crikey Blogs

              loading...

              Smart Company

              loading...

              StartupSmart

              loading...

              Leading Company

              loading...